Technology

Photogrammetry or LiDAR: Which to Choose for a Drone Survey

7 min read By Roman Astalavidze

If the site is open ground and you need an orthophoto, photogrammetry is enough: it costs less and gives a colored, highly detailed result. If trees or shrubs cover the ground and you need an accurate terrain model, choose LiDAR: it measures distances with a laser, and some of the pulses reach the ground through the vegetation. On open ground the accuracy of the two methods is close, so the choice usually depends on what is on the ground, not on the datasheet figures.

Below: how each method works, how they differ, what studies show, when LiDAR is needed and when it is overkill, and how to choose a method for your site in Georgia.

How photogrammetry and LiDAR work

Photogrammetry builds a three-dimensional model from overlapping photographs: software finds the same points in different images and calculates their coordinates. It is a passive method, so it needs light and a distinguishable surface texture. The result is a colored point cloud, a surface model and an orthophoto.

LiDAR is active: it sends out laser pulses and measures how long they take to return. The drone’s position at every moment is determined by satellite navigation and an inertial unit, and from these the coordinates of each point are derived. One pulse can return several times: from the top of a tree, from a branch and from the ground beneath.

How they differ

  • Vegetation. Photogrammetry sees only the top of the canopy or grass, not the ground under it. LiDAR, through multiple returns, gets ground points in gaps in the vegetation.
  • Light and texture. Photogrammetry needs light and a contrasting surface, and it reconstructs uniform areas such as snow or smooth sand poorly. LiDAR barely depends on texture.
  • Thin objects. Wires and thin branches get lost in photos. LiDAR often captures them.
  • Color and detail. Photogrammetry wins here: photographic detail and a colored orthophoto. LiDAR gets its color from a separate camera.
  • Water. Water is a difficult surface for both: photogrammetry cannot see the bottom, and a laser reflects poorly from water.
  • Georeferencing. Photogrammetry relies on RTK and ground control points. LiDAR is built from the drone’s trajectory, but checkpoints are needed in any case to verify the result.
  • Cost. LiDAR equipment and processing cost more, so it pays off where the required terrain model cannot be obtained without it.

What studies show

In one experiment on bare ground and low grass, the terrain model accuracy of LiDAR and photogrammetry was close: root mean square error of about 0.11 m and 0.14 m. But with vegetation taller than 60 cm, the LiDAR error stayed near 0.11 m while the photogrammetry error rose to 0.36 m. The authors noted that photogrammetric accuracy fell by about 0.10 m for every 20 cm of vegetation height, while LiDAR showed no such dependency.

In a forest study under leaf-off conditions, LiDAR covered the ground almost completely, while photogrammetry reached about 81% coverage in a dense young forest. At the densest site only 11% of ground points came from first returns, which is why multiple laser returns matter.

LiDAR is not a magic wand. In a study on runoff modeling over areas with almost complete grass cover, even LiDAR needed ground points and careful data cleaning. Accuracy still has to be confirmed: more in Drone Survey Accuracy: RTK, Ground Control Points and RMSE Explained.

When photogrammetry is enough

  • Open terrain. Fields, construction sites, yards, quarries without overgrowth.
  • You need an orthophoto. A colored, detailed image for design, monitoring and GIS.
  • Stockpile and earthwork volumes. Photogrammetry captures the top of a stockpile very well. More in Drone Volume Measurement: Stockpiles, Quarries and Earthworks.
  • Limited budget. Photogrammetry is usually faster and cheaper.

When you need LiDAR

  • Forest and shrubs. You need a terrain model under vegetation.
  • Mountainous, wooded slopes. Road, power and hydraulic engineering design.
  • Linear objects. Power lines, roads and pipeline routes, where wires and terrain under overgrowth matter.
  • Hydrology and drainage. Runoff calculations need accurate terrain under the plant cover.
  • Difficult light and uniform surfaces. LiDAR depends less on lighting and texture.

When you need both

In complex projects the methods are combined: LiDAR provides terrain under vegetation, and photogrammetry provides a colored orthophoto and detail. Many LiDAR systems carry a camera for coloring the point cloud, but for orthophoto quality it is not always equal to a dedicated photogrammetry camera. If you need an accurate colored orthophoto, agree this in advance.

Which method is needed more often in Georgia

Georgia is a mountainous country: forests cover about 40% of its territory, and more than 90% of the forests grow on the slopes of the Greater and Lesser Caucasus (according to FAO). So on mountainous and wooded sites, and on road and power line routes, the question “LiDAR or photogrammetry” comes up more often than on flat ground.

On open construction sites in Tbilisi and Batumi, at yards, quarries without overgrowth and on flat land such as the vineyards of Kakheti, photogrammetry is usually enough: it is faster and gives a colored orthophoto. Data in Georgia is usually delivered in WGS 84 / UTM zone 37N (the west of the country) or 38N (the east), and cadastral and government tasks may require GGD.

How to choose: four questions

  1. What is on the ground? Open surface or vegetation. This is the main question.
  2. What do you need as a result? A colored orthophoto and volumes, or a terrain model under trees.
  3. What accuracy and tolerance are needed? They set the number of checkpoints and the method.
  4. What are the deadline and budget? Photogrammetry is faster and cheaper, LiDAR is justified by the task.

Describe your site and task, and we will advise which method is needed. We survey a test area of up to 0.5 ha for free.

What to specify in your order

  • the area and location of the site;
  • whether there is vegetation and what kind: grass, shrubs, forest;
  • what you need: orthophoto, terrain, volumes, plan;
  • the required accuracy, separately horizontally and vertically;
  • the coordinate and height systems (in Georgia, WGS 84 / UTM zone 37N or 38N);
  • the deadline.

More about the services: photogrammetry and 3D modeling, LiDAR surveying. What files you receive after the survey is covered in What You Get After a Drone Survey: Point Cloud, LAS, GeoTIFF and DXF.

Photogrammetry or LiDAR: frequently asked questions

Which is more accurate: photogrammetry or LiDAR?

On open ground the accuracy is close. Under vegetation LiDAR is more accurate: in one experiment, with vegetation above 60 cm the terrain model error was about 0.11 m for LiDAR and about 0.36 m for photogrammetry.

Can LiDAR see the ground under trees?

Partly. Laser pulses pass through gaps in the canopy and some return from the ground. In a very dense canopy and continuous grass there are fewer ground points, and accuracy has to be confirmed with ground points.

Do I need ground control points for a LiDAR survey?

LiDAR is built from the drone’s trajectory, so fewer ground control points are usually needed than for photogrammetry. Checkpoints are always needed: without them the result cannot be verified.

Can I get an orthophoto from LiDAR?

LiDAR itself gives a point cloud. A colored orthophoto is built from photographs. Many systems combine LiDAR with a camera, but orthophoto quality depends on the camera.

Which is cheaper: photogrammetry or LiDAR?

Photogrammetry is usually cheaper: the equipment and processing are simpler. LiDAR is justified when the required terrain model under vegetation cannot be achieved without it.

Can I manage with photogrammetry on a site with trees?

Sometimes. In the leaf-off season more ground is visible under deciduous trees, but on conifers and in dense overgrowth it does not help. Then LiDAR is needed.

Which method is chosen more often for sites in Georgia?

It depends on the site. In mountainous and wooded areas, where forests cover about 40% of the country, LiDAR is needed more often. On open sites in cities and on flat ground, photogrammetry is usually enough. Choose the method by what is on the ground and what you need to get.

Project Start

Request a Free Test Flight

We will survey a test area (up to 0.5 ha) of your current project free of charge. You will receive a point cloud or an orthomosaic to verify the data quality in your own CAD software before the project starts.

  • Response within one business day
  • Flight coordination accounting for airspace
  • Sample data in a format that fits your software

By submitting the form, you agree to theconditions of data processing